At Carlile Patchen & Murphy, our Creditors’ Rights Group delivers strategic, business-minded counsel to help clients recover debt, enforce their rights, and navigate complex insolvency issues. Drawing on the firm’s deep bench of legal talent across business, finance, and litigation, we tailor practical solutions to fit each phase of the credit recovery cycle.
Our clients include commercial and consumer credit grantors, banks, credit unions, real estate lenders, professional service providers, and medical groups. Whether collecting an unpaid debt or protecting a secured interest, we ensure creditor rights are asserted with precision and strength.

Clear and consistent remittance, cost, and collection reporting.
Flexible engagement tailored to client-established work standards.
CPM takes a multi-jurisdictional, full-cycle approach to collections, insolvency matters, and proceedings. We prioritize maximum recovery while managing costs and ensuring compliance with the federal code and applicable state laws. Our services are available under hourly or contingent fee arrangements, depending on client preference and case type.
CPM handles commercial collection from demand through final recovery. Most matters begin with a demand letter and a candid assessment of what the account is realistically worth: what the debtor owns, whether the debt is secured, whether a personal guaranty exists, and whether litigation will cost more than it returns. That assessment happens before the invoice starts running, not after.
Where a negotiated resolution is possible, we pursue it. Forbearance agreements, payment plans and workout arrangements frequently recover more, faster, than a contested judgment — particularly where the debtor is still operating and wants to stay that way. Where the account requires litigation, we file promptly and move.
For banks, credit unions and other secured lenders, we address defaults across the full range of collateral: accounts receivable, inventory, equipment, vehicles and real property. That includes reviewing perfection before enforcement begins — an unperfected or lapsed security interest changes the strategy entirely — and pursuing commercially reasonable dispositions under Article 9 of the Uniform Commercial Code, along with any deficiency that remains. Where a cognovit note is in play, we advise on whether and how to use it, since Ohio permits confession of judgment on commercial debt but not consumer debt, and the distinction matters.
When a commercial tenant stops paying, the landlord is usually weighing three questions at once: recover the space, recover the arrears, or restructure the lease. We work through all three, including forcible entry and detainer actions, claims against guarantors, and the treatment of lease obligations when a tenant files for bankruptcy protection. Acting early materially improves outcomes here; a landlord who waits two quarters is generally negotiating from a weaker position than one who moves in the first.
Detinue is a claim for the return of specific personal property being wrongfully held, together with damages for the period of wrongful detention. It applies where the property itself is what matters — equipment a former contractor will not return, goods delivered but never paid for, collateral a defaulting borrower has kept.
The remedy is worth pursuing where the property has value that money damages alone would not capture, or where the debtor’s ability to satisfy a money judgment is doubtful but the asset is identifiable and reachable. We advise creditors on which claim fits the facts, since detinue, replevin and conversion overlap and the right choice depends on whether you want the property back, its value, or both.
Replevin recovers possession of personal property before final judgment, rather than waiting for a case to conclude. In Ohio it is governed by Chapter 2737 of the Revised Code, and it moves quickly: the creditor files, the court sets a hearing on the right to possession, and where the creditor prevails an order of possession issues.
Speed is the point. For collateral that depreciates, moves or disappears — vehicles, equipment, inventory — the difference between recovering it this month and next is often the difference between recovering value and recovering scrap. We handle the possession hearing, the bond requirements and enforcement of the order, and where the property has already been sold or transferred, we pursue the proceeds instead.
When recovery requires litigation, CPM’s creditors’ rights attorneys work alongside the firm’s Banking & Finance and Business Transactions groups, so that the lawyer arguing the case understands the underlying loan, lease or contract as well as the one who papered it.
We bring and defend breach of contract claims, guaranty enforcement actions, fraudulent transfer claims where assets have been moved out of reach, and priority disputes among competing lienholders.
A judgment is not a recovery. The work that produces money begins after it is entered: debtor examinations, garnishment of wages and bank accounts, judgment liens against real property, certificates of judgment filed in every county where the debtor holds assets, and receivership where a business needs to be operated or wound down under court supervision. We also pursue domestication of Ohio judgments in other states, and enforcement of foreign judgments here, which is routine for creditors whose debtors have relocated or hold assets across state lines.
For secured real estate lenders we handle commercial foreclosure from complaint through sheriff’s sale and confirmation, including receiverships to preserve income-producing property during the case, and deficiency claims where the sale does not satisfy the debt. Where a deed in lieu or a negotiated sale produces a better net result than foreclosure, we say so.
A bankruptcy filing stops collection immediately, but it does not end a creditor’s rights. We file and defend proofs of claim, seek relief from the automatic stay where collateral is not adequately protected, object to discharge or to the dischargeability of particular debts, defend preference and fraudulent transfer demands brought against our clients, and represent creditors on committees and in plan negotiations.
Give us a call or send a message with any inquiries and legal questions.
© Copyright 2026 – Carlile Patchen & Murphy LLP | Terms and Conditions | XML Sitemap